Why this story

Why it matters
The case helped shape a safety debate. The withdrawal changes the evidentiary record clinicians and regulators draw on when they review advice.
Attention gap
Ori’s seven-day headline-index search recorded 0 of 11 outlets with at least one relevant headline. The publisher located specialist reporting and checked the editors’ reproduced notice and the FDA record. Targeted panel searches did not establish a matching current report. Index coverage varies by outlet.

The Lancet has withdrawn a 2006 paper that attributed an infant’s death to opioid exposure through breast milk after the mother took codeine. Retraction Watch reported the decision on November 20 and obtained statements from the journal and Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children, where the investigation took place.

The investigators found that the report left out the infant’s blood levels of codeine and acetaminophen, along with evidence of codeine in the stomach. The editors said that the omissions amounted to falsification and deprived readers of information needed to judge the authors’ conclusion.

The case report was among the sources cited in a 2017 U.S. Food and Drug Administration safety communication. The FDA’s codeine information page still links its recommendation against use in breastfeeding women. A journal’s withdrawal of one piece of evidence does not itself revise the agency’s advice.

What the evidence cannot tell us

  • This is a report about a retraction, not a new study of codeine safety. The investigation did not establish a new cause of death.

What to watch

Watch for a regulator or professional society to publish an explicit review of the evidence behind its guidance.

Read the sources. Credit the work.

The reporting and documents behind this brief, linked directly to the source. Verified publisher and author credits appear where available; other entries show their actual website address. Several links may draw on the same underlying reporting or research.

  1. Retraction Watch

    Lancet retracts report by former SickKids pediatrician on infant’s death from opioid poisoning (opens in a new tab)

    retractionwatch.com · November 20, 2026

    Reporting / analysisContent read for this publication · November 22, 2026

    Publisher credit checked November 22, 2026. View credit on the source page (opens in a new tab).

  2. The Lancet editors, reproduced by Wendy Jones

    Text of the Lancet editors’ retraction notice, reproduced with link to journal (opens in a new tab)

    breastfeeding-and-medication.co.uk · November 20, 2026

    Primary document / sourceContent read for this publication · November 22, 2026

    Publisher credit checked November 22, 2026. View credit on the source page (opens in a new tab).

  3. U.S. Food and Drug Administration

    Codeine Information (opens in a new tab)

    fda.gov

    Primary document / sourceContent read for this publication · November 22, 2026

    Publisher credit checked November 22, 2026. View credit on the source page (opens in a new tab).

This story was written and checked using AI against the linked evidence. No routine human review is claimed. Read the method.

Suggest an update or correction
Published corrections